Case No.: IT-98-34-T


Judge Liu Daqun, Presiding
Judge Maureen Harding Clark
Judge Fatoumata Diarra

Mr. Hans Holthuis

Decision of:
4 October 2002





The Office of the Prosecutor:

Mr. Kenneth Scott

Counsel for the Accused:

Mr. Kresimir Krsnik, for Mladen Naletilic
Mr. Branko Seric, for Vinko Martinovic


TRIAL CHAMBER I, SECTION A ("the Chamber") of the International Tribunal for the Prosecution of Persons Responsible for Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law Committed in the Territory of the Former Yugoslavia since 1991 ("the Tribunal"),

BEING SEISED OF the "Appeal Against the Adoption of Documents P292.1, P628.1 and P628.2", filed by the Martinovic Defence on 20 September 2002;

NOTING the oral arguments of the parties during the hearing on 16 September 2002;

CONSIDERING that in principle, exhibits should be submitted through a witness;

CONSIDERING that, pursuant to Rule 89 (C) of the Rules of Procedure and Evidence ("the Rules"), "[a] Chamber may admit any relevant evidence which it deems to have probative value";

CONSIDERING that the Appeals Chamber has held that "[t]here is no legal basis that proof of authenticity is a separate threshold requirement for the admissibility of documentary evidence";1

CONSIDERING, however, that in accordance with the jurisprudence of the Tribunal, it is required that the evidence presents "sufficient indicia of reliability";2

CONSIDERING that the party conducting the direct examination of a witness must lay the source of the document it wishes to submit through the witness, in order for that document to meet the required degree of reliability;

CONSIDERING that the party conducting the cross-examination of a witness must lay the background and the source of the documents it wishes to submit through the witness, in order to allow the witness to recognise or reject the document;

CONSIDERING furthermore that the mere admission of a document does not necessarily mean that the document gives an accurate portrayal of the facts;3

RECALLING that the decision to authorise the admission of a document is without prejudice to the value or weight which will be accorded to the document at the final stage of the trial;

NOTING that during the hearing on 19 September 2002, the Prosecutor sought the admission into evidence of exhibits P292.1; P578.1; P620.4; P624.1; P628.1; P628.2 and P719.1;

NOTING that exhibits P620.4 and P624.1 were admitted orally by the Chamber on 19 September 2002;

CONSIDERING that in the Submission, the Martinovic Defence has not objected to the admission into evidence of exhibits P578.1 and P719.1;

NOTING that another document previously submitted bears the identification number P578.1; that accordingly, the Registry has renumbered the present exhibit as P578.01;


PURSUANT to Rules 54 and 89 of the Rules,

HEREBY ORDERS that the following exhibits are admitted into evidence:

P578.01; P628.1; P628.2; P719.1;

DENIES the admission of exhibit:


REMINDS the parties that, unless otherwise ordered, any objection to the list of exhibits submitted by the other party must be filed within seven (7) days of the date of the filing of the said list.


Done in both English and French, the English version being authoritative.

Dated this fourth day of October 2002,
At The Hague,
The Netherlands

Judge Liu Daqun
Presiding Judge

[Seal of the Tribunal]

1 - Prosecutor v. Delalic et al., "Decision on Application of Defendant Zejnil Delalic for Leave to Appeal against the Decision of the Trial Chamber of 19 January 1998 for the Admissibility of Evidence", Case No. IT-96-21-AR73.2, 4 March 1998, at para. 25.
2 - Ibid., at para. 17; See also, Prosecutor v. Aleksovki, Decision on Prosecutor's Appeal on Admissibility of Evidence, Case No. IT-95-14/1-A, 16 February 1999; Prosecutor v. Kordic and Cerkez, Decision on Appeal Regarding Statement of a Deceased Witness, Case No. IT-95-14/2-A, 21 July 2000; Prosecutor v. Brdanin and Talic, Order on the Standards Governing the Admission of Evidence, Case No. IT-99-36-T, 15 February 2002, at para. 18.
3 - Ibid.


Follow on X | Database Scope | Terms & Conditions | About

Copyright 1999- WorldCourts. All rights reserved.